Sport card values are determined by the player, the year, the grade, and scarcity. The following 25 NFL cards are the highest prices cards sold on eBay over the last month.
The Junk Wax era for NFL cards covers the years 1986 to 1994. With the biggest price in July 2023 being $1,893 across 46 bids. Cards featuring Brett Favre and Barry Sanders appear multiple times on this list, reinforcing their popularity among collectors.
See who makes the top-25 highest-selling NFL cards from the Junk Wax era on eBay below:
RELATED: Use The JunkWax10 Coupon At Checkout On BCW Supplies For 10% Off
25. 1989 TOPPS Troy Aikman, PSA 10, $66
- Sale Price: $66
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 3964
- Bids: 18
- Pack Price: $125
24. 1989 Pro Set Deion Sanders, PSA 10, $77
- Sale Price: $77
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 1106
- Bids: 23
- Pack Price: $42
23. 1990 Score Emmitt Smith, $84
- Sale Price: $84
- Grade: SGC 9
- Bids: 14
- Pack Price: $15
22. 1990 Pro Set Joe Montana, $102
- Sale Price: $102
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 86
- Bids: 36
- Pack Price: $4
21. 1989 TOPPS Barry Sanders, $103
- Sale Price: $103
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 6202
- Bids: 21
- Pack Price: $125
RELATED: 8 Most Valuable Tom Brady Rookie Cards
20. 1994 Score Marshall Faulk, $109
- Sale Price: $109
- Grade: SGC 9
- Bids: 6
- Pack Price: $29
19. 1991 Fleer Bo Jackson, $109
- Sale Price: $109
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 50
- Card Population At PSA 10: 12
- Bids: 6
- Pack Price: $11
18. 1989 Score Tim Brown, $117
- Sale Price: $117
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 842
- Bids: 12
- Pack Price: $1595
17. 1986 TOPPS Joe Montana, $125
- Sale Price: $125
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 263
- Card Population At PSA 10: 23
- Bids: 27
- Pack Price: $8000
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Aaron Rodgers Rookie Cards
16. 1990 TOPPS Derrick Thomas, $133
- Sale Price: $133
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 49
- Bids: 39
- Pack Price: $10
15. 1989 Pro Set Barry Sanders, $140
- Sale Price: $140
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 2716
- Bids: 66
- Pack Price: $42
14. 1990 TOPPS Emmitt Smith, $157
- Sale Price: $157
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 4349
- Bids: 8
- Pack Price: $10
13. 1986 TOPPS Reggie White, $162
- Sale Price: $162
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 636
- Card Population At PSA 10: 43
- Bids: 5
- Pack Price: $8000
RELATED: The Most Valuable Super Bowl Merch Since 1966
12. 1989 Score Derrick Thomas, $169
- Sale Price: $169
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 767
- Bids: 6
- Pack Price: $179
11. 1986 TOPPS Jerry Rice, $196
- Sale Price: $196
- Grade: BGS 8.5
- Bids: 23
- Pack Price: $8000
10. 1992 Wild Card Brett Favre, $199
- Sale Price: $199
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 2
- Card Population At PSA 10: 2
- Bids: 16
- Pack Price: $44
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards
9. 1994 TOPPS Joe Montana, $202
- Sale Price: $202
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 84
- Card Population At PSA 10: 6
- Bids: 30
- Pack Price: $18
8. 1991 TOPPS Brett Favre, $217
- Sale Price: $217
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 1974
- Bids: 20
- Pack Price: $40
7. 1993 Wild Card Brett Favre, $222
- Sale Price: $222
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 3
- Bids: 17
- Pack Price: $54
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Eli Manning Football Cards
6. 1989 Score Bo Jackson, $227
- Sale Price: $227
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 584
- Bids: 30
- Pack Price: $179
5. 1992 wild Card Barry Sanders, $235
- Sale Price: $235
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 1
- Bids: 8
- Pack Price: $44
4. 1986 McDonald’s Play & Win Reggie White, $250
- Sale Price: $250
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 108
- Bids: 25
- Pack Price: NA
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Justin Herbert Rookie Cards
3. 1991 Wild Card Brett Favre, $625
- Sale Price: $625
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 14
- Bids: 25
- Pack Price: $55
2. 1989 Score Barry Sanders, $1,280
- Sale Price: $1280
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 2192
- Bids: 28
- Pack Price: $1595
RELATED: 12 Most Valuable Bills Memorabilia Perfect for the Bills Mafia
1. 1990 Pro Set Ludwell Denny, $1,893
- Sale Price: $1893
- Grade: NA
- Bids: 46
- Pack Price: $15
Conclusion
- Unexpected Leader: The 1990 Pro Set card of Ludwell Denny, an unexpected leader, topped the chart with a selling price of $1,893. Interestingly, this card was not graded, yet it secured a staggering 46 bids.
- Consistent Stars: Barry Sanders and Brett Favre are two names that consistently dominated the list. A 1989 Score card featuring Sanders was the second-highest selling at $1,280. Favre’s Wild Card from 1991 secured the third spot at $625.
- Grading Matters: The grading companies PSA and BGS were frequently seen, with PSA holding a prominent spot. Cards graded 10 generally fetched higher prices, emphasizing the significance of card conditions in determining value.
- Rookie Legends: Some of the iconic players of the era like Joe Montana, Reggie White, and Jerry Rice made appearances with Montana’s 1994 TOPPS card at ninth place, selling for $202, and Rice’s 1986 TOPPS card garnering $196.
- Diversity in Value: The selling prices varied, ranging from Ludwell Denny’s at $1,893 to Troy Aikman’s 1989 TOPPS card at $66, showcasing the broad spectrum of collector interest and market valuation.
Explore the top NFL cards sold on eBay in June or more junk wax card values below:
- Top 25 Highest-Selling NHL Cards from the Junk Wax Era on eBay (June 2023)
- Top 25 Highest-Selling NBA Cards from the Junk Wax Era on eBay – June 2023
- Top 25 Highest-Selling MLB Cards from the Junk Wax Era on eBay – June 2023