12 Most Valuable Bills Memorabilia Perfect for the Bills Mafia

If you are a big football fan, you may have a hankering to start a fan collection. As a member of the Buffalo Bills Mafia, you might be looking for how to best start or bolster a valuable collection of Bills memorabilia. While these top twelve items are big hitters, it’s important to remember that not all vintage Bills memorabilia will be worth thousands. It depends on how valuable the player is or the year. It has to be rare, graded, or feature a significant player who made an impact on the game while active in the NFL. Keep reading to see the twelve most valuable Bills memorabilia available on eBay now.

12. Men’s OVO Buffalo Bills Varsity Jacket: $2300

You’ll stand out from the crowd wearing this vintage NFL varsity jacket. The midweight jacket’s stand-up collar, quilted inside, and full-zip front will keep you warm as the temperature lowers. For all necessities, there are numerous pockets available. This fashionable jacket is the ideal option for any style-conscious person thanks to its fake leather sleeves, base felt chenille team logo patches, and 3D embroidery, making this one of the most valuable Bills memorabilia available for superfans and collectors alike. 

11. 1993 Leather Reversible Buffalo Bills/Dallas Cowboys Super Bowl Jacket: $2500

This is 1 of 3 original hand-crafted Jeff Hamilton 1993 Super Bowl varsity jackets, all leather on one side, with a “super bowl” leather lettering, satin reversible side. There were only 3 sold at the 1993 Buffalo Bills vs. Dallas Cowboys game at the Rose Bowl. One was bought by Bruce Smith, and the other by MJ Hammer, with this final available item being sold by its original owner.

The lease says this original design of color and descriptive emblems is unique. The reversible satin side has a slight separation in the satin strands towards the top, near the collar, but the main leather side is in excellent condition, making this one of the most valuable Bills memorabilia available to own now.

Check Out: Most Valuable Super Bowl Merch Since 1966

10. Vintage Jeff Hamilton Buffalo Bills Leather Reversible Satin Letterman Jacket: $2500

This Vintage 90’s Buffalo Bills Leather Reversible Letterman Jacket is an original Jeff Hamilton Design, tagged as an XL. This jacket measures 25 inches across and 27 inches long, having been made in the USA originally. This jacket is entirely of Italian Lambskin Leather with a reversible satin lining emblazoned with leather Bills script. The leather is not in completely perfect condition, but this vintage jacket is being sold new without tags as it has not been worn previously. This is an exclusive item perfect for any member of the Bills Mafia to add to their Bills collectibles. 

9. Vintage Buffalo Bills Bobblehead Figure: $3000

What is outdated is updated. With this Buffalo Bills Retro Vintage Bobblehead, you can relive the past in your fan cave. This bobblehead depicts a classic, vintage player carrying a football and donning a team-colored helmet, game day uniform, and other gameday gear. Because he needs to represent the team, the helmet and jersey both have the logo.

Its base in team colors that will look fantastic in your collection. If there were any concerns about your allegiances, there is a team logo display on top of the base. For a little extra team enthusiasm, the wordmark team name is displayed on the base’s front. This figure was handcrafted and painted by hand, making it one of the most valuable Bills memorabilia available now. 

Also Read: Rare And Vintage Basketball Jerseys Worth Collecting

8. Buffalo Bills Vintage Denim Sleeveless Jacket: $3000

The artist wanted to express their creativity and passion for the Buffalo Bills after purchasing this denim vest 20 years ago in its original, all-red form. The designer assembled a variety of patches and expertly sewed them into the jacket while also creating a mural on the back. This clearly required the most effort and time. This ONE-OF-A-KIND vest took a lot of time to create and is one of the most valuable Bills memorabilia as such. The painting depicts a Buffalo Stampede with a Jet crashing, a Dolphin being trampled in the mud, and Tom Brady’s jersey being trodden upon.

Additionally, there are numerous Buffalo Bills pins on the front and lower back. All of the buttons are Buffalo Head Nickels, and the inside of the back is lined with a t-shirt.

7. NFL Buffalo Bills #34 Thurman Thomas Jersey: $4000

With the addition of this Thurman Thomas-autographed blue Mitchell & Ness replica jersey with the “HOF 2007” inscription, you may enhance your collection of Buffalo Bills memorabilia. It’s the ideal way to showcase your love for the Buffalo Bills for years to come, whether exhibited in your home or business. At such a high price, this is one of the most valuable Bills memorabilia perfect for collectors and Bills Mafia alike.

6. 1960s Vintage Buffalo Bills Sweatshirt: $4000

Go big in displaying your loyalty to the Buffalo Bills with this AFC All Over 2.0 pullover sweatshirt. On the front and back, it has eye-catching Buffalo Bills graphics. Additionally, coordinated sleeve stripes highlight your fervent support even more. This is a true vintage 1960s piece in excellent condition from when the NFL was called the AFL. If you’re looking for some of the most valuable Bills memorabilia and a piece of football history, this exclusive vintage sweatshirt is perfect for you. 

Check Out: Best Sports Cards To Invest In 2023

5. Vtg Buffalo Bills Pro Cut OJ Simpson Jersey Champion 1970s: $4000

Blue retro custom football jersey with O.J. Simpson’s signature. OJ Simpson memorabilia is still a popular topic for collectors and sports enthusiasts alike because it is a big part of American pop culture and sporting history. The item is accompanied by a numbered tamper-proof hologram from Schwartz Sports Memorabilia as well as an online verifiable Certificate of Authenticity. This authentic 70s vintage piece is unique and perfect for an OJ fan or other Bills Mafia fan looking for the most valuable Bills memorabilia.

4. NFL Swarovski Crystal Buffalo Bills Helmet: $4900

This is a genuine full-size Riddell helmet that has more than 11,000 Swarovski crystals all over it.  On Instagram, under the handle @sports_bling, there is a video of this that captures the dazzle considerably better. About 3 weeks pass between custom orders, so this is a perfect investment for any superfan or collector looking for unique pieces of Bills memorabilia.

Also Read: Most Expensive Rookie Cards Ever

3. Damien Covington Game-Worn Autographed Jersey: $7995

In the National Football League (NFL), linebacker Damien Emere Covington played professionally. The Buffalo Bills picked him in the third round of the 1995 NFL Draft out of North Carolina State University. He played three seasons (1995–1997) for the Bills. He was visiting a friend’s flat when he was slain in an attempted robbery. Because this is a signed jersey from Covington’s rookie season, this is an incredibly unique and one-of-a-kind item for a committed collector. As Covington’s career was cut very short, he signed very few items, making this game-worn jersey one of the most valuable Bills collectibles out there.

2. 2018 Josh Allen RC National Treasures Plate 1/1 PSA Auto 10: $14,950

Joshua Patrick Allen, a quarterback with the Buffalo Bills of the National Football League, was born on May 21, 1996. He was taken seventh overall by the Buffalo Bills in the 2018 NFL Draft while playing college football for the University of Wyoming, where he was the MVP of a bowl game.

In 2020, Allen had a breakthrough campaign, leading the Bills to their first division title and playoff triumph since 1995 and a berth in the AFC Championship Game. In addition to being selected to the Pro Bowl and second-team All-Pro, Allen set single-season records for throwing yards and touchdowns for the Bills club. He has guided Buffalo to a total of four postseason appearances, three back-to-back division titles, and four postseason triumphs during his time as a coach.

This National Treasures plate is one-of-a-kind and extremely rare, emblazoned with this iconic quarterback’s authenticated signature. If you’re in the Bills Mafia and looking to collect some of the most valuable Bills memorabilia of all time, this is a perfect opportunity to own a piece of Buffalo Bills history. 

1. HOF Andre Reed’s ‘91 Buffalo Bills Championship NFL Ring: $30,000 Most Valuable Bills Memorabilia

Without a doubt, Andre Reed was a unique athlete. The seven-time Pro Bowl participant and member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame was a legendary wide receiver!

The 1991 Buffalo Bills Super Bowl XXVI “AFC” Champions 10K Gold & Diamond Ring is simply stunning and 100% genuine. It is 40.1 grams in weight and roughly a size 11. His initials are etched within the Jostens ring, which was made. With only minor wear, it is in excellent condition. 

This ring comes with a letter of authenticity signed by Andre Reed and is a wonderful addition to the collection of any Buffalo Bills fan looking for the most valuable Bills memorabilia. 

With 87 touchdown receptions in NFL history, Reed is ranked 15th overall, while his 85 postseason receptions place him ninth overall.

Ella is a digital content intern and loves writing about entertainment, media, technology, and culture. She is a rising... More about Ella Burch