10 Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards

most valuable patrick mahomes rookie cards

Sports memorabilia can be extremely valuable depending on the story behind it, the condition of the item, and the nature of the collectible. One of the most common collectibles is trading cards. Football cards are some of the most popular, especially when the featured player has reached extreme fame.

As we all know well by now, Patrick Mahomes is a quarterback for the Kansas City Chiefs in the NFL who made his debut in 2017 and just led the chiefs to a Super Bowl victory in 2023. When a player makes their debut, there are a series of cards produced from their first season that are known as “rookie” cards. These cards can be extremely valuable and there are a whole host of Patrick Mahomes rookie cards out there. Here we will explore the most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards and how much they’re worth as of this year.

10. 2017 Certified Cuts Patrick Mahomes RC Auto Patch #204 /49

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Certified Cuts #204
Source: eBay – user blowoutcards2

This Mahomes rookie card features a jersey patch piece in the top right corner. There are two factors which make this card one of the most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards. The first being the limited run of just 49 copies produced and the second being a large authorized signature. This value is not surprising based on the fact that there are two unique collectibles included. Anything with a signature instantly increases in value.

Card Value: $2,000

9. 2017 Limited Patrick Mahomes RC Auto Patch #136 /149

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Auto Patch #136
Source: eBay – user perimetercollectibles

One of the factors that makes a football card valuable is the amount that are printed. Although this next entry is one of the most common Patrik Mahomes rookie cards out there, it can still be extremely valuable in good condition. It features a full body picture of Patrick Mahomes and a bold signature alongside a patch piece of his jersey for added effect. Again, these two factors instantly bring up the value of this card.

Card Value: $3,000

Check Out: Most Valuable Super Bowl Merch Since 1966

8. 2017 Immaculate Collection Patrick Mahomes RC Auto Patch #104 /99

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Immaculate #104
Source: eBay – user mc_sportscards

There is a certain set of cards that are known as the immaculate collection. These are incredibly sought after by collectors and this Patrick Mahomes card is no exception. With the immaculate collection logo, a strong Patrick Mahomes stance, a jersey swatch, and an authentic signature, there is plenty here that inflates the price massively. 

Card Value: $5,000

7. 2017 Immaculate Collection Patrick Mahomes RC Auto Patch #104 /99

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Impeccable #104
Source: eBay – user cardboom4collectors

This next card utilizes the capstone concept to inset four separate swatches in around a central image of Patrick Mahomes. There is also an addition of the signature at the bottom of the card. This only serves to make this one of the most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards ever made. It certainly looks unique, which collectors always look for in rookie cards.

Card Value: $6,000

6. 2017 Panini XR Patrick Mahomes RC Auto Triple Jersey #164 /25

We mentioned that card rarity contributes massively to any card’s value and this next card only had 25 base versions ever made. It features a smaller image of Patrick Mahomes in the corner with a large diagonal triple swatch of patches across the face of the card. On top of all of this, it features a distinct signature sticker to increase the value even further. 

Card Value: $9,000

Also Read: 10 Most Valuable Aaron Rodgers Rookie Cards

5. 2017 Panini Impeccable Patrick Mahomes RC Autograph Patch/Helmet #107 /75

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Panini Impeccable #107
Source: eBay – shanegray22

We have featured quite a few cards on this list which feature the player’s shirt pieces in swatches, but this next entry actually features a helmet piece. This unique addition makes it incredibly collectible, alongside the face that only 75 were ever made. It shows Mahomes in a signature stance pointing out at his teammates, so any Chiefs fan would want to find this card in mint condition.

Card Value: $20,000

4. 2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes RC Autograph #132 /20

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Panini #132
Source: Goldinauctions

The 2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes RC Autograph is a card which was printed in a run with just 20 copies. This makes it potentially the rarest Patrick Mahomes rookie card out there. It features a simplistic design with an elegant Flawless logo framing the player’s name. As we’ve seen, it can’t be this valuable without a signature, so his unique signature is also prominent written with a blue sharpie.

Card Value: $30,000

3. 2017 Panini Contenders Optic Patrick Mahomes RC Autograph #103

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Panini #103
Source: eBay – bgsgemcards

This unique Patrick Mahomes card features the contenders styling with ticket information on the front of the card. With a subtle, pastel coloring and a clear signature at the base of the car, it is the pride of many collectors. Less than 300 copies were ever made, which makes this “rookie ticket” a card worth collecting.

Card Value: $50,000

2. 2017 Panini Contenders Patrick Mahomes RC Autograph #303

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Panini #303
Source: eBay – user buynicecards

We go from one contenders card to another. This version had less than 250 copies ever produced. While it is very similar to the previous entry, this rookie card has a golden background and a foil contenders logo underneath the ticketing information on the card. It also features the signature in the same position, which explains why both cards are estimated to have the same value today.

Card Value: $50,000

1. 2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes RC Auto Patch #161 /99

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards: 2017 Panini #161
Source: Psacard

With just 99 copies, this card is the pinnacle of collectability and is by far the most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie card. There is a very large signature underneath the player striking a strong pose. Alongside this, there is a massive jersey patch all framed in a clean white card with elegant detailing. All of these factors mean it can fetch an incredibly high sale price at auction. In mint condition, this card actually holds the record for the sale price of a Patrick Mahomes card. 

Card Value: $400,000

Check Out: 8 Most Valuable Tom Brady Rookie Cards

How many Patrick Mahomes rookie cards are there?

So there you have a definitive list of the most valuable Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards, but how many actually exist? All in all, there are 37 unique Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards and each of these has a number of possible variations.

As you can see, the main factors in value are the number of cards produced, the inclusion of clothing or gear, and his signature. The significance of his first ever Super Bowl win have an impact on the card value. If you’re a collector and love the Chiefs, you could sell your prized cards this year and see a major return on your investment. However, if you want to hold on, they will probably increase in value over time. Mahomes isn’t done with the NFL yet, so the best could be yet to come.

Allison is a seasoned writer with five years of experience in editorial roles throughout the publishing industry. She graduated... More about Allison Curley