Who says stuffed animals aren’t a great collectible? Beanie babies are a classic example of cuteness overload in the world of collectibles. Created in 1993, they became a sensation quickly for both children and adults. They not only were good gifts but were great investment ventures.
But what are the rarest beanie babies 2024 has to offer? Whether you have these valuable beanie babies or are on the hunt to finish your extensive collection, these rare beanie babies are hard to come by and are worth thousands. From the adorable Batty the Bat to the rare Libearty, these are the 5 rarest beanie babies in 2024.
5. Batty the Bat, $10,000
Batty the Bat is one of the rarest beanie babies 2024 has so far. The bat is made out of brown material with velcro on its wings to let you fasten it together. The beanie baby was introduced in October 1997, and its birthday is the 29th of October in 1996.
Interestingly enough, there are two variations of Batty: the brown version and a dark tie-dyed version. He retired in March 1999, making him a high-valued item for collectors, with the most recent sale being $10,000 on eBay. You can find several on secondary marketplaces for around that same value.
Related: Extensive Beanie Babies Birthday and Beanie Boos Birthday Guide
4. Scorch the Dragon with Errors, $12,000
Scorch the Dragon is another one of the rarest Beanie Babies 2024 has to offer. But what makes him so special? It’s his errors. Beanie Babies with errors are usually more valuable as they’re hard to find. Errors include the wrong tags, misspellings, punctuation errors, and even production errors.
For Scorch, his $12,000 value comes from a Tush Tag Error where Oak Brook is spelled Oakbrook. This particular Scotch is the tie-dye various, not the brown, with iridescent red wings and green felt sikes that match his claws.
Check Out: McDonald’s Beanie Babies Value Guide
3. Tuffy the Terrier with Errors, $18,000
Tuffy the Terrier is a normal Beanie Baby that isn’t valued high until there are errors. The average price for the error-filled pup is around $10,000 to $18,000, depending on the condition. Tuffy is a light brown terrier with a dark brown-black tail.
His birthday is the 12th of October 1996 and retired on the 31st of December 1998, making him a must for collectors. The errors that can be found on Tuffy include a misspelling on the front of Swing Tag, and Oak Brook being misspelled. Some with a higher value also have no “UK” after TX5, and an extra space between “Date of Birth” and “:”.
Also Read: Most Expensive Beanie Babies
2. Libearty, $75,000
The Libearty bear is one of the rarest Beanie Babies 2024 has seen so far. The $75,000 value bear is patriotic, featuring a white bear with an American flag on his chest and a red and blue ribbon to complete his theme of Independence Day.
He originally released with a Summer Olympics 1996 birth date but later was taken out due to copyright issues, so now it just has a Summer 1996 tag. This bear comes with a rare heart necklace with errors, making it a must-grab for collectors.
Read More: Beanie Baby Tag Errors To Look Out For
1. Princess Diana Bear, $500,000
Princess the Bear, also known as Princess Diana Beanie Baby, is the rarest Beanie Babies 2024 thanks to its rarity. The purple bear with a white rose on its chest was sold in December 1997 to benefit the Diana, Princess of Wales memorial fund. It was heavily sought after during its sale since the shipments were limited to just 12 per licensed retailer.
Now you can find these bears around secondary marketplaces for as low as $1,000 to as high as $1 million. One listing has it in a beautiful box with a certification of authenticity for a whopping $500,000.
