How Much Is a Lou Gehrig Baseball Card Worth?

How Much Is Lou Gehrig Baseball Card Worth Credit Wiki Commons, Lou Gehrig
Credit: Wiki Commons

If you want to find the best and most valuable Lou Gehrig baseball cards, then look no further. Not only will we highlight some of the highest-priced rookie and non-rookie cards, from the 1951 Topps Card worth $19,000 to the 1925 Exhibits card worth up to $800,000, but we’ll also talk about the overall value.

While Lou Gehrig has several high-valued cards, for example, his 1932 U.S. Caramel #26 card, these are by far the top-valued Lou Gehrig baseball cards.

RELATED: How to Tell if a Baseball Card is Worth Money

Who is Lou Gehrig?

lou gehrig baseball cards, credit: unsplash

Henry Louis Gehrig, also known as just Lou Gehrig, was a professional baseball first baseman who played 12 seasons in Major League Baseball for the New York Yankees, from 1923 to 1939. Gehrig was renowned for his “prowess as a hitter and for his durability, earning him his nickname “The Iron Horse”. He was also regarded as one of the greatest baseball players of all time.

He was an All-Star seven consecutive times, a Triple Crown winner, an American League Most Valuable Player twice, and a member of six World Series Champion teams. Throughout all of his high achievements and incredibly successful career, it’s not a surprise that the man has some of the most valuable baseball cards within the MLB franchise.

Are Lou Gehrig Cards Worth Investing?

Yes. Any type of sports memorabilia is worth collecting if you know what to look for.

For instance, if you want to invest in Lou Gehrig cards, you’ll want to check out his rookie cards, as they are incredibly valuable and rare, which means their value will go up over time.

Most Valuable Lou Gehrig Rookie Cards

3. 1933 Delong Lou Gehrig #7, $264,000


Heritage Auctions is home to some of the biggest sales, especially in sports memorabilia. December 2020 brought yet another large sale to Lou Gehrig fans. The 1933 Delong Lou Gehrig #7 is one of the many valuable rookie baseball cards, and with this one only graded at an NM-MT 8.5, the highest known grading as of now, it received a bid of over $260,000.

2. 1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig #92, $274,950


The first rookie card on the list that is graded at a MINT 10, is the 1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig #92 which was auctioned off at Memory Lane Inc. in September of 2007. Even if you don’t find a card that is MINT-10, the 8.5 grading card is worth upwards of $78,000, and a grading 9 is just as valuable as a MINT-10, making it a great addition to any collection.

1. 1925 Exhibits Henry L. Gehrig, $801,960


What’s incredible about this RC listing is that this staggering value of over $800,000 is only a grade 6 of the 1925 Exhibits Henry L. Gehrig. This is one of the most valuable Lou Gehrig baseball cards in existence and one that is sought after by all sports fans and sports memorabilia collectors. This card was sold off at Goldin Auctions in 2021 and is the highest graded value for this card. It’s only a matter of time before another pops up with a higher grading, causing an even higher price tag.

READ MORE: Most Wanted Baseball Cards 1990s: Including Chipper Jones

Most Valuable Lou Gehrig Non-Rookie Cards Overall

3. 1930 Fleer Lou Gehrig #28, $3,957.40


While rookie cards will always be worth more than non-rookie cards, there are still some amazing finds when looking for non-rookie Lou Gehrig baseball cards, with one being the 1960 Fleer #28 card. With a MINT-10 grading, this card was sold at Memory Lane Inc. in September of 2008 for over $3,900.

2. 1961 Topps Gehrig Benched #405, $4,316.90


Working our way up the list, we have the second most valuable non-rookie Lou Gehrig baseball card the 1961 Topps Gehrig Benched #405 card, which was sold at the Mile High Card Company in March of 2015. The minimum bid was set at $200 but the final bidding reached $4,300 for a MINT-10 grading.

1. 1951 Topps Connie Mach’s All-Stars Lou Gehrig, $19,800


At our number one spot for the most valuable non-rookie Lou Gehrig baseball card that is not a rookie card is the 1951 Topps Connie Mack’s All-Stars which sold at Heritage Auctions in December of 2019. With a grading of NM-MT 8, this reached a value of over $19,000, which only means that when a higher grading comes around, it’ll be worth even more.

CHECK OUT: Most Valuable Deion Sanders Rookie Cards

Where to Find Lou Gehrig Baseball Cards

If you’re interested in getting ahold of some of Lou Gehrig’s baseball cards yourself, then you’ll have to look at secondary marketplaces. Several auction houses like Heritage Auctions, Goldin Auctions, and even Memory Lane Inc. have a large roster of rare and valuable baseball cards.

Other secondary marketplaces could be helpful as well like eBay. And if you’re worried about potentially getting scammed through this option, eBay has become a great place especially since they launched their Authentication for Trading card programs.

Under this program, eBay offers a guarantee on any ungraded card sold on its platform for $250 or higher. The grading system is provided by CSG (Certified Sports Guarantee), a newer grading competitor in the sports card industry.

When purchasing a card, the card will be sent to CSG where it will be examined to check for authenticity. If they determine that the card is authentic, they will ship it to the buyer with a sleeve with a bar code confirming the authenticity.


Lou Gehrig has one of the most successful careers in MLB history and is one of the most well-known baseball players in the franchise, which means his cards are worth a higher price than most.

If you’re interested in getting ahold of some of his cards, then check out these great options. With this guide, you now have a clearer idea of what his cards are worth and how you can get ahold of them.

Nikole Stewart is a writer and editor with three years of experience writing keen articles on topics such as... More about Nikole Stewart

Mentioned In This Article:

More About: