Top 25 Highest-Selling Football Cards from the Junk Wax Era on eBay (September 2023)
Dive into the thrilling world of junk wax-era American Football cards with our eBay roundup of the top 25 sales in September 2023.
Launching our countdown is the 1989 Score Tim Brown card, marking its value at a respectable $103. As we ascend the ladder, the prices escalate, reaching a climax with a staggering 1990 Score Emmitt Smith selling for an impressive five-figure sum. Traverse through the list to uncover treasures such as the 1989 Score Barry Sanders, the 1994 Miami Bumble Bee Dwayne Johnson, and the 1990 Upper Deck Deion Sanders.
Join us on this nostalgic info-packed journey as we recount pop counts, grades, bids, prices, and more. Don’t miss out on the full breakdown below.
RELATED: Use The JunkWax10 Coupon At Checkout On BCW Supplies For 10% Off
25. 1989 Score Tim Brown, $103
- Sale Price: $103
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 843
- Bids: 16
- Pack Price: $1595
24. 1989 Score Bruce Matthews, $103
- Sale Price: $103
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 216
- Bids: 9
- Pack Price: $1595
23. 1991 Pro Set Brett Favre, $113
- Sale Price: $113
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 284
- Bids: 14
- Pack Price: $4
22. 1988 Topps Bo Jackson, $127
- Sale Price: $127
- Grade: SGC 9.5
- Bids: 12
- Pack Price: $269
21. 1987 Topps Wilber Marshall, $130
- Sale Price: $130
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 9
- Bids: 7
- Pack Price: NA
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards
20. 1989 Topps Barry Sanders, $152
- Sale Price: $152
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 6262
- Bids: 8
- Pack Price: $124
RELATED: The Most Valuable Super Bowl Merch Since 1966
19. 1990 Pro Set Emmitt Smith, $167
- Sale Price: $167
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 712
- Bids: 17
- Pack Price: $4
18. 1989 Score Thurman Thomas, $172
- Sale Price: $172
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 1355
- Bids: 27
- Pack Price: $1595
17. 1990 Topps Emmitt Smith, $185
- Sale Price: $185
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 4373
- Bids: 39
- Pack Price: $20
16. 1992 Stadium Club Brett Favre, $190
- Sale Price: $190
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 1589
- Card Population At PSA 10: 2822
- Bids: 60
- Pack Price: $35
15. 1989 Pro Set Barry Sanders, $202
- Sale Price: $202
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 2742
- Bids: 18
- Pack Price: $70
14. 1988 Starting lineup Ken Easley, $211
- Sale Price: $211
- Grade: BGS 8.5
- Bids: 12
- Pack Price: NA
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Aaron Rodgers Rookie Cards
13. 1993 Fleer Michael Strahan, $218
- Sale Price: $218
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 148
- Bids: 42
- Pack Price: $80
12. 1989 Topps Deion Sanders, $219
- Sale Price: $219
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 3121
- Bids: 48
- Pack Price: $124
11. 1989 Score Derrick Thomas, $224
- Sale Price: $224
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 711
- Bids: 31
- Pack Price: $1595
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Justin Herbert Rookie Cards
10. 1990 Pro Set Fred Marion, $235
- Sale Price: $235
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 29
- Card Population At PSA 10: 4
- Bids: 4
- Pack Price: $4
9. 1990 Upper Deck Deion Sanders, $280
- Sale Price: $280
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 591
- Bids: 50
- Pack Price: $20
8. 1990 Topps Junior Seau, $373
- Sale Price: $373
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 88
- Bids: 25
- Pack Price: $20
7. 1989 Score Michael Irvin, $391
- Sale Price: $391
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 725
- Bids: 391
- Pack Price: $1595
RELATED: 10 Most Valuable Eli Manning Football Cards
6. 1991 Stadium Club Brett Fave, $575
- Sale Price: $575
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 90
- Card Population At PSA 10: 68
- Bids: 43
- Pack Price: $5
5. 1989 Score Troy Aikman, $665
- Sale Price: $665
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 1640
- Bids: 36
- Pack Price: $1595
4. 1989 Score Barry Sanders, $1,232
- Sale Price: $1232
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 2204
- Bids: 24
- Pack Price: $1595
3. 1989 Score Deion Sanders, $1,338
- Sale Price: $1338
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 904
- Bids: 37
- Pack Price: $1595
2. 1994 Miami Bumble Bee Dwayne Johnson, $1,661
- Sale Price: $1661
- Grade: PSA 9
- Card Population At PSA 9: 51
- Card Population At PSA 10: 33
- Bids: 30
- Pack Price: NA
RELATED: 8 Most Valuable Tom Brady Rookie Cards
1. 1990 Score Emmitt Smith, $2,150
- Sale Price: $2150
- Grade: PSA 10
- Card Population At PSA 10: 766
- Bids: 31
- Pack Price: $21
Conclusion
As we wrap up our review for August 2023, the spotlight undeniably falls on the 1990 Score Emmitt Smith card, reaching an outstanding sale price of $2,150, notably standing out amongst the array of American football collectibles. Despite a relatively ample PSA 10 population of 766, the fervor of 31 bids showcased the unwavering allure Emmitt Smith holds for enthusiasts.
Fascinatingly, the unique 1994 Miami Bumble Bee card featuring Dwayne Johnson, before his ascent to Hollywood stardom, snagged a notable $1,661, a testament to the cross-appeal of celebrities in the sports card realm. The card, graded PSA 9, boasts a limited population, adding a layer of exclusivity to this unconventional collectible.
The 1989 Score series made a strong showing, with Deion Sanders and Barry Sanders cards fetching impressive amounts of $1,338 and $1,232 respectively, reinforcing the enduring appeal of this series among collectors. The fervent bidding and high sale prices, despite substantial card populations, underscore the lasting significance of these football icons.
The roundup also saw entries with lower card populations, such as the 1990 Topps Junior Seau and the 1993 Fleer Michael Strahan, which commanded respectable prices of $373 and $218 respectively. These cards, along with others in the lineup, exemplify the eclectic mix of players and card types that captivate collectors’ interests.
Explore the top NFL cards sold on eBay in August or more junk wax card values below:
- Top 25 Highest-Selling Baseball Cards from the Junk Wax Era on eBay (August 2023)
- Top 25 Highest-Selling Hockey Cards from the Junk Wax Era on eBay (August 2023)
- Top 25 Highest-Selling Basketball Cards from the Junk Wax Era on eBay (August 2023)
More About:Rarities